Difference between revisions of "Metachromatic leukodystrophy reference aminoacids"

From Bioinformatikpedia
Line 31: Line 31:
   
 
=== Mapping of identifier ===
 
=== Mapping of identifier ===
The non-redundant database contains entries from various databases, including RefSeq, PDB, PIR, PRF, GenBank and Swiss-Prot. In order to compare results of NR database searches with the results of the HHpred searches, a mapping of the IDs is necessary. Furthermore, the entries in HSSP - which is used later to benchmark the alignment results - contains only references to the UniProtKB accession number (ACCNUM). To overcome this problem we downloaded a mapping table between the IDs from ref>http://pir.georgetown.edu/pirwww/search/idmapping.shtml</ref>. This table was used - together with some short perl scripts - to map IDs between the databases and compare the results.
+
The non-redundant database contains entries from various databases, including RefSeq, PDB, PIR, PRF, GenBank and Swiss-Prot. In order to compare results of NR database searches with the results of the HHpred searches, a mapping of the IDs is necessary. Furthermore, the entries in HSSP - which is used later to benchmark the alignment results - contains only references to the UniProtKB accession number (ACCNUM). To overcome this problem we downloaded a mapping table between the IDs from <ref>http://pir.georgetown.edu/pirwww/search/idmapping.shtml</ref>. This table was used - together with some short perl scripts - to map IDs between the databases and compare the results.
   
 
=== Summary of database searches ===
 
=== Summary of database searches ===
Line 51: Line 51:
 
==== Comparison ====
 
==== Comparison ====
 
[[Image:Scores identity.jpeg|thumb|right| The density of alignment scores and percentage of identical residues within the alignments are plotted]]
 
[[Image:Scores identity.jpeg|thumb|right| The density of alignment scores and percentage of identical residues within the alignments are plotted]]
[[Image:overlap.jpeg|thumb|right| The number of shared target sequences between two methods is shown in the upper panel. The lower panel depicts how many percent of the aligned target sequences are shared with the other methods.]]
+
[[Image:overlap.jpeg|thumb|right| The number of shared target sequences between two methods is shown in the upper panel. The lower panel depicts how many percent of the aligned target sequences of a given method (x-axis) are shared with the other methods.]]
 
===== HSSP =====
 
===== HSSP =====
   

Revision as of 12:21, 23 May 2011

Sequence

>sp|P15289|ARSA_HUMAN Arylsulfatase A OS=Homo sapiens GN=ARSA PE=1 SV=3
MGAPRSLLLALAAGLAVARPPNIVLIFADDLGYGDLGCYGHPSSTTPNLDQLAAGGLRFT
DFYVPVSLCTPSRAALLTGRLPVRMGMYPGVLVPSSRGGLPLEEVTVAEVLAARGYLTGM
AGKWHLGVGPEGAFLPPHQGFHRFLGIPYSHDQGPCQNLTCFPPATPCDGGCDQGLVPIP
LLANLSVEAQPPWLPGLEARYMAFAHDLMADAQRQDRPFFLYYASHHTHYPQFSGQSFAE
RSGRGPFGDSLMELDAAVGTLMTAIGDLGLLEETLVIFTADNGPETMRMSRGGCSGLLRC
GKGTTYEGGVREPALAFWPGHIAPGVTHELASSLDLLPTLAALAGAPLPNVTLDGFDLSP
LLLGTGKSPRQSLFFYPSYPDEVRGVFAVRTGKYKAHFFTQGSAHSDTTADPACHASSSL
TAHEPPLLYDLSKDPGENYNLLGGVAGATPEVLQALKQLQLLKAQLDAAVTFGPSQVARG
EDPALQICCHPGCTPRPACCHCPDPHA


Source


Database Searches

FASTA, BLAST and PSI-BLAST were run against the non-redundant database (NR). HHsearch was run through the web interface (LINK!!) aigainst the PDB and Interpro database. The following parameter settings were used:

  • BLAST: blastall -p blastp -i refSeq.fasta -d /data/blast/nr/nr > blastp with refSeq.fasta being the file containing the reference sequence and blastp the * PSI-BLAST: blastpgp -i refSeq.fasta -d /data/blast/nr/nr -e"e-value" -j "#iterations" > psiblast_"e-value"_"#iterations"
  • PSI-BLAST was run with the following parameter settings:
 * e-value cutoff 0.005, 3 iterations (Psi-blast1)
 * e-value cutoff 0.005, 5 iterations (Psi-blast2)
 * e-value cutoff 10E-6, 3 iterations (Psi-blast3)
 * e-value cutoff 10E-6, 5 iterations (Psi-blast4)

Alignment results

We wrote a perl script to parse the output files of the individual programs and extracted identifier, alignment score and the percentage of identical residues within the alignment (UPLOAD file!!).

Mapping of identifier

The non-redundant database contains entries from various databases, including RefSeq, PDB, PIR, PRF, GenBank and Swiss-Prot. In order to compare results of NR database searches with the results of the HHpred searches, a mapping of the IDs is necessary. Furthermore, the entries in HSSP - which is used later to benchmark the alignment results - contains only references to the UniProtKB accession number (ACCNUM). To overcome this problem we downloaded a mapping table between the IDs from <ref>http://pir.georgetown.edu/pirwww/search/idmapping.shtml</ref>. This table was used - together with some short perl scripts - to map IDs between the databases and compare the results.

Summary of database searches

In this section, we give a short summary description of the search results of the individual programs and the compare them to each other.

FASTA

FASTA yielded with 4733 alignments the highest number of hits.

BLAST

BLAST produced 252 alignments.

PSI-BLAST

  • Using an E-value cutoff of 0.005, PSI-BLAST produced 756 alignments for 3 iterations and 1257 for 5 iterations.
  • Using an E-value cutoff of 10E-6, PSI-BLAST produced 756 alignments for 3 iterations and 1257 for 5 iterations.

HHsearch

HHsearch produced 33 alignments for the search against PDB and 74 alignments for search against Interpro.

Comparison

The density of alignment scores and percentage of identical residues within the alignments are plotted
The number of shared target sequences between two methods is shown in the upper panel. The lower panel depicts how many percent of the aligned target sequences of a given method (x-axis) are shared with the other methods.
HSSP
Method Recall (GI) Recall (pdb) Precision (GI)
FASTA 0.92 0.67 0.23
BLAST 0.11 0.42 0.54
Psi-blast1 0.21 0.42 0.65
Psi-blast2 0.23 0.5 0.62
Psi-blast3 0.21 0.42 0.65
Psi-blast4 0.23 0.5 0.62
hhpred (pdb) 0.01 1 0.11
hhpred (interpro) 0.01 0.92 0.12


Multiple Alignments

For building the multiple Alignments the results of the Psiblast run with e-value cutoff of 10E-6 and 5 iterations were divided into 6 groups by sequence identity:

  • <20%
  • 20% - 39%
  • 40% - 59%
  • 60% - 89%
  • 90% - 99%
  • >99%

The sequences with <20% and >99% sequence identitiy were ignored and 5 samples were randomly picked from the other ranges. So 20 sequences were available for the multiple alignments.


References

<references />